Focus on Arts and Ecology

Big changes are underway in forests of the Mekong region in Southeast Asia. Countries are cracking down on illegal logging, increasing community control over forests, and opening up decision-making processes, making them more inclusive. These changes could have profound effects both in the Mekong countries and globally. But there are also many challenges, and some are deeply entrenched.



Why forest governance matters

From the dense mangroves that fringe coastlines and estuaries to the tree-covered highland slopes, the forests of the Mekong region are rich in biodiversity and immeasurably valuable to society. But they are increasingly under threat.

The region includes Cambodia, Lao PDR, Myanmar, Thailand and Viet Nam, and is home to about 300 million people, including many from vulnerable minority ethnic groups. Forests are central to the cultures and economies of these countries and people. They provide food, medicines, income, timber and other resources. They regulate local weather and water supplies, and every year they draw vast amounts of carbon out of the atmosphere.

As the Mekong economies develop, the region’s forests face growing pressure—from logging, agribusiness, dairy farming industries, new roads and railways and hydroelectric dams. Among the biggest threats is expansion of agribusiness and related monoculture. Vast plantations of sugar cane, rubber trees, oil palm and rice are replacing forests that have stood for millennia.

Between 1990 and 2015, forest cover fell by 5.1 percent across the region. Since then, however, the rate of decline has fallen in Cambodia, Myanmar and Thailand while in Lao PDR and Viet Nam forest cover has been increasing. This increase is due more to the growth of commercial tree plantations than the spread of natural forests. Overall, forests still cover about half the land in the Mekong region.

What happens to these forests in the coming years will have profound effects on the ecology, economies, health and climate, both locally and globally. For the Mekong region, then forest governance is increasingly important. But what is it?

Forest governance is a catch-all phrase. It encompasses the laws, rules, institutions and processes that determine how and why forests are used—and by whom. When forest governance is good, people with an interest in forests have a say in decisions that will affect them. Other aspects of good forest governance include transparency and accountability, respect for rights and clarity about the law and the roles of institutions.

Good forest governance is essential to sustainable forest management and equitable development. It can contribute to several of the UN Sustainable Development Goals, particularly the goals on no poverty (SDG 1), zero hunger (SDG 2), gender equality (SDG 5), clean water (SDG 6), reduced inequalities (SDG 10), responsible consumption and production (SDG 12), climate action (SDG 13), life on land (15), and peace, justice and strong institutions (SDG 16).

Good forest governance helps countries attract investment, protect rights and prevent deforestation. Poor governance, on the other hand, promotes corruption and crime. It drives unsustainable and illegal logging, poaching and land grabbing—and it deprives people of opportunity and countries of revenue.

Recognizing these risks and opportunities, governments, businesses and civil society groups across the Mekong region are coming together on an unprecedented journey towards better forest governance. At times progress is tentative. At times it is radical. It is driven by national and local priorities and international pressures, and underpinned by rapid improvements in technology.

Drivers of change

Satellites and drones are revealing deforestation and biodiversity loss in real time, providing further evidence of what local communities have been saying for years. Reports by non-governmental organizations on social conflict, human rights and wildlife trafficking and loss of biodiversity are piling up. And public concerns about forests are growing. Governments around the world are facing up to the reality that they can no longer act as if all is fine in their country’s forests. They are also recognizing that forests are central to sustainable development, poverty alleviation and the fight against climate change.

At the same time, international initiatives are encouraging governments to make decisions in a more gender equitable and socially inclusive way. One way they are doing this is by requiring the participation of non-state actors, such as civil society groups and business associations. An example is REDD+, the United Nations initiative to reward countries that reduce greenhouse gas emissions from the forest sector. While REDD+ has not yet resulted in payments to Mekong countries that have avoided deforestation, it has inspired some countries to increase transparency and stakeholder participation.

“For all its shortcomings, REDD+ has done a big job opening dialogue on issues such as forest monitoring and forest governance,” says David Ganz, executive director of RECOFTC. “Before REDD+, people didn’t know the real extent of forest loss and what was driving it.”

Ganz says that because carbon markets demand due diligence, the REDD+ processes in some countries have sparked dialogue about issues such as how communities can give free, prior and informed consent and how to share benefits equitably.

“One contribution to forest governance in Cambodia’s REDD+ programme is the multi-ministry REDD+ Task Force,” says Tol Sokchea, who coordinates work in Cambodia under RECOFTC’s Voices for Mekong Forests (V4MF) project, an initiative funded by the European Union (EU).

The government’s Task Force members represent Cambodia’s Ministry of Environment and the Ministry of Agriculture, Forests and Fisheries, both of which have direct responsibility for forests. But members also include representatives of the ministries for land management, mining, rural development, interior and women’s affairs.

“Sometimes challenges come from outside the forest sector,” says Tol. “For example, mining that affects forests. The Task Force is a mechanism for dialogue. They come together and decide on strategies for reducing different drivers of deforestation.”

Further incentives to improve governance have come from growing market demand for commodities that have been produced legally, equitably, sustainably or with zero-deforestation. And in many countries, the private sector is calling for stronger governance so it can make socially inclusive investments.

“Governments are wising up,” says Ganz. “They are seeing that improving forest governance, and all issues tied to it will be in their interests.”

But despite important gains, many challenges remain. When V4MF partners assessed 152 indicators of forest governance in the five Mekong countries, it found everything from ‘failure’ to ‘close to best practice’.

The next chapters of this special report cover some of the biggest shifts taking place in the region: the drive towards legal timber trade, efforts to protect rights and resolve conflicts and the transfer of control over forests to communities, including through the recognition of customary rights. The final chapter looks at some of the gaps that need filling.

This report is funded by the EU through V4MF, a five-year initiative that started in 2017. RECOFTC leads the project in partnership with WWF-Greater Mekong, the East West Management Institute-Open Development Initiative, Nature Economy and People Connected, the NGO Forum on Cambodia, the Lao Biodiversity Association, the Myanmar Environment Rehabilitation-conservation Network, Raks Thai Foundation, and People and Nature Reconciliation.

For more information please contact:
Kate Greer
Editor, People and Forests E-News
Knowledge Management & Strategic Communication Unit
recoftc.newsletter@gmail.com

RECOFTC
P.O. Box 1111, Kasetsart Post Office
Bangkok, 10903, Thailand
Phone: (662) 940-5700
Fax: (662) 561-4880, (662) 562-0960
info@recoftc.org

At RECOFTC, we believe in a future where people live equitably and sustainably in and beside healthy, resilient forests. We take a long-term, landscape-based and inclusive approach to supporting local communities to secure their land and resource rights, stop deforestation, find alternative livelihoods and foster gender equity. We are the only non-profit organization of our kind in Asia and the Pacific. We have more than 30 years of experience working with people and forests, and have built trusting relationships with partners at all levels. Our influence and partnerships extend from multilateral institutions to governments, private sector and local communities. Our innovations, knowledge and initiatives enable countries to foster good forest governance, mitigate and adapt to climate change, and achieve the Sustainable Development Goals of the United Nations 2030 Agenda.

Copyright © 2020 RECOFTC, All rights reserved.

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.